The Rankings For The Top 4 Of Nashville Star . . .
I am going to leave out Coffey from these rankings since he was eliminated this evening . . .
Round One
1. Shaun Mayer - Gretchen Wilson song . . . don't know the name of the song . . . WOW! She was wonderfully in control of her voice and the stage.
2. Melissa Lawson - She sang a little "Hit me with your best shot" . . . It was quite good in the way that she always is . . . just not her best . . .
3. Gabe Garcia - I was unsure from the beginning what this song was . . . he was wonderful as per usual . . . I was just a little underwhelmed by the song, and its lack of intensity . . .
Round Two
1. Melissa Lawson - Singing a little Carrie Underwood, I've got to tell ya, she was spot on. I was a little worried with doing such a recognizable song, but man, she just nailed it . . .
2. Shaun Mayer - Slowing it down a bit, this girl just did a phenomenal job . . . She has really improved in the past few weeks . . .
3. Gabe Garcia - I love him . . . very much . . . and his vocals are very much on spot . . .but, he just didn't have the umph for my taste.
Overall rankings . . .
1. Melissa Lawson - Her second song was just a bit better than Shaun's first
2. Shaun Mayer - A close second here . . . They could very potentially be tied for first.
3. Gabe Garcia - He is so good, but I think both of his performances were out done by the girls.
From these rankings, it would seem obvious that I think the two girls will be the final two . . . I have no idea how Nashville Star will eliminate the third . . .they may wait until the end, or they may do it in the middle of the show . . . either way, I think that Gabe and Melissa will be the final two and that Melissa Lawson will be out winner.
Nobody is leaving comments, so, come on, y'all! Give me your opinions!
THIS is AMERICAN IDOL!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f635b/f635b7138b3ad4a0ed36f5b7ac82c75ac05c872e" alt="<i><b>THIS</b> is AMERICAN IDOL!</i>"
IDOL IS BACK!!!
Monday, July 28, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Sorry for the delay on the comments! We have been dealing with a family health crisis - that we thought was somewhat under control - but apparently is not! :(
Thought we should at least take a minute or two for something fun and entertaining though...I thought the show last night was really good!
We missed the previous week -but overall we agree with you in the assessment. Coffey seem like a nice guy - but it was time for him to move on. I was kinda shoeked how many folks were at Gabe's concert! That was fantastic! :)
I am not sure exactly who needs to win - but I am rooting for Gabe and Melissa. I would be happy for any of them - they all seem to genuinely want it and need it.
Great reviews as always J! :)
Post a Comment